Benefits System Pushes Manchester Families to Breaking Point as Deaths Mount

A respected anti-poverty campaigner who spent years fighting for vulnerable families became another casualty of Britain’s benefits system when she was found dead at her Stockport home aged 46, an inquest heard.

Karen McBride’s death in 2022 came after she received letters claiming she owed hundreds in housing benefit debts - money that officials later admitted she never actually owed. The mother-of-four, who received Personal Independence Payment, had her housing benefit wrongly suspended when her son turned 19, leaving her facing homelessness and “frustrated to the point of desperation,” according to the coroner.

McBride’s case mirrors that of Kristie Hunt, a 31-year-old aspiring nurse from Stockport who took her own life in 2023 after being chased for over £1,000 in supposed benefit overpayments. An inquest heard how Hunt, who had returned to work after 13 years of mental health struggles, was wrongly investigated by the DWP’s counter-fraud team and penalized for employment support allowance she never actually owed. The department’s failure to properly record her employment status also led Stockport Council to incorrectly demand £800 in housing benefit repayments.

The pattern of vulnerable people being driven to desperation extends across Greater Manchester. Tracy Hailwood, who spent 33 years caring for her severely disabled daughter Stacey, faces homelessness after her carer’s allowance was stopped following her daughter’s death. The 52-year-old from Cheadle, whose body is broken from decades of lifting her child, says the DWP told her to “just get a job” despite having no work history and severe physical limitations.

“I did everything for Stacey for 33 years so I have no work history,” Hailwood explained. “I wasn’t just Stacey’s mother and carer, I was her personal assistant. I did all the gastrostomy and tracheostomy changes, I trained up support workers for the 30 hours a week from continuing care.” Now forced to sell her home, she faces sofa-surfing between relatives while battling deteriorating mental health.

Even qualified professionals aren’t immune to the system’s failures. Nadine Rich, an NHS district nurse from Wythenshawe, has been trapped in temporary accommodation for 14 months with her three-year-old daughter. Despite working 30 hours weekly, the 39-year-old can’t afford full-time hours because housing benefit rules would leave her unable to pay rent on her temporary flat. The £875 monthly rent consumes her housing benefit, while £60 weekly petrol costs for commuting leave her choosing between work and providing for her child.

“I am getting the rent paid for, but I am being forced into poverty,” Rich said. “It’s either my child or my job. If I was just put in the appropriate property, it would be different.”

The DWP maintains it “always provides the best possible support to those who need it,” citing carer’s allowance payments that continue “for several weeks after someone’s caring role ends.” A government spokesperson highlighted their Plan for Change, which includes raising the national living wage and increasing benefits, while acknowledging challenges in the interaction between universal credit and housing benefit.

But for those caught in the system’s labyrinth, such promises ring hollow. As Karen McBride spent years campaigning before her death: “Poverty kills.” The question now facing officials is how many more vulnerable people must suffer before fundamental reforms address what coroners and devastated families alike describe as a benefits system contributing to deaths across the region.

---

Source: Read original article